The Other Man by Michael Bergin reads like a novel. It is incredibly engrossing – is that the right word? I could not put it down and basically spent all day immersed in this true story from the former model’s perspective.
I loved this book. Michael Bergin starts with the day he meets Carolyn Bessette in New York City in the early ’90s only a few days after he’d moved to New York City to pursue a modeling career.

He then goes back in time to his youth growing up in Connecticut, his family, friends, early and awkward relationships, and some hijinks leading to fights and stuff like that. This part is so honest because he allows himself to be vulnerable. Naturally, the reader (me) immediately cares about him.
Michael meets Carolyn in a bar. They have an on-again off-again thingy that is sex driven but it is also about visiting his family on weekends and later her family all while she is also seeing John F. Kennedy, Jr.
Carolyn is secretive about her life – deflecting direct questions (“he’s just a friend”) and that part is so weird. I guess people who date multiple partners have to do that because otherwise they wouldn’t be able to continue stringing them along.
My take was that Michael didn’t have a lot of money and she liked surrounding herself with wealthy people and had the expectation she would manifest riches. He would go on these modeling assignments and the pay was actually less than what it cost to travel to the venue after paying the modeling agency their cut and paying photographers to get the photos for his portfolio and whatnot.

He wins the Calvin Klein underwear campaign after Marky Mark is essentially fired for a past indiscretion (a combo of fighting and spewing racial slurs). But Michael seems sure that Carolyn had nothing to do with getting him that job. I kind of think she did. I think that she wanted him to be successful and she must have put a good word in for him/vouched for him. She was the publicist for CK and they valued her opinion.
The climb to fortune takes a back seat to fame for Michael but eventually he becomes an actor and moves to Los Angeles for Baywatch. I think the most surprising reveal, aside from her three abortions, was that Carolyn continues seeing him after she gets married.
I don’t understand how she was able to be incognito at that time, that part, IDK, I mean, she visited him in California and they walked around the neighborhood and went into shops together and nobody noticed? It was different in the ’90s. I don’t think cell phones had cameras, right? I didn’t get a cell phone until 2014 so I have no idea when that technology started making stealth actions harder to maneuver.

I wonder what her mother thought of this book. And I wonder if Carolyn confided in her family regarding her feelings, her decisions and all that or if she was so emotional (borderline personality disorder???) because she didn’t feel she could trust anyone. She appears clingy and needy one minute and distant the next – what the hell is that?
That speculation – that’s what we all do to fill in a narrative. We use our own perspective to decipher someone else’s life because we are busy bodies who love to pass judgment. And Michael confesses to sharing his life with his family. His parents knew about Carolyn before they met her, as his parents are depicted as highly supportive and loving.
After I finished reading the book, I Googled him. I am happy to report that Michael Bergin is now a successful real estate agent and he is still with his wife Joy. He married her in 2004, the same year the book was published. They are a beautiful couple with two lovely children who are now adults, a daughter who is modeling and a son who plays baseball for the Marlins.
I think the only way Michael Bergin could have moved on with his life is the way it happened. Not to say that Carolyn had to die so tragically, but their rather toxic relationship, IMO, would have never gone the distance. It was almost as if people who have such a strong physical connection sometimes cannot verbalize their feelings and the result is excessive fighting. Maybe it has to do with not being able to come to terms with perceived flaws or insecurities, or just not trusting in positive outcomes. I really don’t know.
I remember when JFK Jr.’s plane went down and we were all glued to the TV news hoping it wasn’t true, hoping they would be found alive and safe, because we all thought John-John would be the POTUS one day. But none of us knew him.
Maureen Callahan has this YouTube channel called The Nerve where she loves to debunk things – like when she finds out hot gossip or sourced out truth about celebs, she takes them to the woodshed, lol. And she has a lot to say about the Kennedys and how they destroyed and still destroy the women surrounding them. She thinks that Carolyn’s husband was a dumb-ass.
People will believe what they want to believe. I choose The Other Man. It’s quite a remarkable “love story”. And P.S., Michael Bergin is still very handsome. I wish him only the best.



















































































